- Phinney
- Elizabeth b. 1695, d. a 9 Oct 1746
- Pickett
- Rebecca b. 30 Jun 1650
- Pickworth
- Ruth b. c 1614
- Picton
- Margaret b. c 1850
- Pier
- Oliver b. c 1741
- Pierce
-
Hannah b. 15 Sep 1713
Mary b. c 1763, d. 30 Mar 1825
Unknown b. c 1860 - Pilcher
- Aryanna H b. c 1796
- Pillsbury
- William b. 27 Jul 1656, d. 12 Oct 1734
- Pineo
-
James b. c 1687
Submit b. 19 Oct 1717, d. 12 Feb 1804 - Pinnegar
- William b. c 1690, d. 3 Feb 1732/33
- Pinney
- Sarah b. 19 Nov 1648
- Pitts
-
Elizabeth b. c 1625, d. a 1696
William b. c 1595 - Placzek
-
Eno
Tekla - Plant
- John b. c 1686
- Planting (Blandin)
-
Clarissa b. c 1780
Nancy b. c 1783
Obadiah b. c 1757